The Ingram | Olheiser team has helped clients recover millions of dollars for injury and wrongful death claims. We are aggressive personal injury attorneys who care deeply about our clients.

Attorneys & Staff

Our personal injury lawyers, legal assistants, paralegals and business development staff work as a tightly knit legal team to ensure your case is handled efficiently from start to finish. Below is a glimpse of our team and the roles we each play at Ingram | Olheiser, PC.

Meet The Team

R. Todd Ingram


Scott Olheiser


Nichole Collier


Jeremy Thies




R. Todd Ingram

Todd Ingram attended law school at Denver University and graduated in the top two percent of his class. He served as a law clerk to the Honorable William F. Downes, United States District Court, in Casper, Wyoming. The Department of Justice subsequently recruited Ingram to handle high-profile, multi-million dollar injury cases on behalf of the United States. After four years with the Department, Ingram returned to Casper to begin a private practice. Licensed in Wyoming and Colorado, his practice has been dedicated to helping those who've been injured or lost a loved one due to the carelessness of others. Ingram’s clients have received some of the largest personal injury verdicts and settlements in Wyoming history. Over the course of his career, Ingram has developed special expertise helping persons with serious brain injuries, nerve damage, and complex medical problems often caused by auto accidents and medical negligence. Ingram’s community activities include coaching youth baseball and serving on the Natrona County School Board. He and his wife Nichole have two children.


Scott Olheiser

Scott's family has lived in Wyoming for five generations. He attended Natrona County High School in Casper where he graduated with Honors. He then attended college at Claremont McKenna College (“CMC”) in Claremont, California where he earned a bachelor's degree in government and economics, with honors. After graduating from college, Scott returned to Wyoming and earned a law degree from the University of Wyoming, College of Law. While in law school, Scott was the president of the Student Chapter of the Wyoming Trial Lawyers Association and was on the Senior Staff of the Land and Water Law Review.

After law school, Scott served as a law clerk to the Honorable William F. Downes, Chief Judge of the United States District Court for the District of Wyoming. After his clerkship, Scott remained in Casper and focused his practice on complex civil and criminal litigation. Scott has a strong desire to obtain justice for people who have been injured by the careless and reckless acts of others. Over the last decade and a half, Scott has worked tirelessly on his client’s cases securing millions of dollars in verdicts and settlements on behalf of his clients. Time after time, Scott has shown his clients that he is willing to do what is takes to bring insurance companies to justice.

Scott was the president of the Wyoming Trial Lawyers Association in 2014 and 2015. He is also a graduate of the prestigious Trial Lawyers College three week course in September of 2012. Scott is currently a board member of the Wyoming Trial Lawyers Association and is licensed to practice law in all state and federal courts of Wyoming and Colorado.

Of Counsel



Nichole Collier grew up in Casper. She attended law school at George Mason University School of Law in Arlington, Virginia, graduating in 2003. After law school, she clerked for the Judges of the Seventh Judicial District Court. Starting in 2004, Nichole went to work for the State of Wyoming Public Defender’s Office and practiced as a deputy public defender for 5 years. During the term of her public defender service, she represented hundreds of clients in cases ranging from misdemeanor DUIs to First Degree Murder. Collier conducted over 20 jury trials in both district court and circuit court, winning numerous acquittals in challenging cases. Starting in 2009, Collier went into private practice focusing primarily on criminal law. In 2014, she became a Magistrate Judge for both the Casper Municipal Court and the Natrona County Circuit Court. Nichole is licensed in both Wyoming and Colorado.

Collier is very active in the community. She was on the Board of the Community Action Partnership of Natrona County from 2008-2016. She also volunteers numerous hours to her children’s schools as well as the Dual Language Immersion Steering Committee. She spends her free time with her husband and two children.


Jeremy Thies

Jeremy Thies grew up in Casper. After graduating high school he lived in Oregon for several years snowboarding on Mount Hood and working toward his pilot’s license. He ultimately returned to his home state to attend the University of Wyoming and in 2010 graduated with a bachelor's degree in Criminal Justice. During his studies, Jeremy began working with Ingram | Olheiser as a legal assistant and has now taken over as the office manager.

Every minute Jeremy is not at the office, he is out enjoying the outdoors. He enjoys hiking, camping and photography.